Stem cells, Alzheimer’s, and the contumely of the Discovery Institute


Minions of the Discovery Institute don't restrict themselves to only fighting for the indoctrination of high school students with creationism—they've also got a wider goal of infusing society with their anti-science dogma. One Discovery Institute Fellow, Wesley Smith, has been all over the place ranting against stem cell research lately, typically with as little actual grasp of the facts as the DI usually brings to bear against evolution.

For instance, how is this for a lovely title: "Embryonic Stem Cell Research Likely Won't Cure Any Diseases"? Now that's doom-and-gloom for you. The gist of his argument is that 1) biotech companies are not getting rich on embryonic stem cell research now, and 2) it won't work anyway. The first point is irrelevant. Basic research often isn't going to be immediately profitable, which is why we need government sponsorship; that our current administration has actively crippled this kind of research might, perhaps, be contributing to the reluctance of the biotech industry to leap into it.

His second point is backed up with some incredibly dishonest quote mining. What he does is quote scientists as being discouraging about the prospects for the research, while omitting key conclusions that contradict his points.

Continue reading "Stem cells, Alzheimer's, and the contumely of the Discovery Institute" (on Pharyngula)


What’s sad about the Lies Institu I mean, Discovery Institute, is that though they have no science, they have spent a lot of time and money, with some good software, to create a very scientific and professional appearance. Considering that an estimated 5% of people click pop-ups and buy things from spam, this means it’s inevitable some % of the public will fall for it. All they have to do to become politically unstoppable is publish a fake scientific journal. Assuming they don’t already. Even the cold fusion nuts have a ‘journal’. When that happens, we’ll be in an even worse situation. Of course, if they do that, we can have a lot of fun making up fake articles with total nonsense math, mixed in with the right creationist pseudoscience, and Sokal them.

Let’s see…what would make a good title.…how about “Characteristic Bessell Functions in Explanatory Filter Observables.”…

Unfortunately they have a fake scientific journal that thay call “peer-reviewed.” As I said in the past, any two astrologers can have a joutnal and call it “peer-reviewed.”

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by PZ Myers published on June 14, 2004 5:47 PM.

Metamorphosis was the previous entry in this blog.

We want to hear from you is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.



Author Archives

Powered by Movable Type 4.381

Site Meter