Quote mining elevated to quote mania

| 7 Comments

After a group of ultra-Orthodox rabbis issued a “fatwa” forbidding Jews even to touch books by Rabbi Nathan Slifkin, he became kind of a celebrity. The popularity of his books jumped dramatically. A number of reviewers (and blurb writers) proceeded to extol the merits of Slifkin’s literary output, and specifically of his latest book titled The Challenge of Creation. Slifkin asserted in this book that scientific theories including evolution theory, not only are fully compatible with the tenets of Judaism, but that all science is in fact rooted in the Torah. The list of blurbs for Slifkin’s book includes those by Professor Michael Ruse, and by a number of other university professors, and prominent rabbis.

There is, though, at least one reviewer whose opinion of Slifkin’s opus is quite different from the acclaims by Slifkin’s admirers. His review, titled “When Quote Mining Becomes Quote Mania” can be read at Talk Reason..

7 Comments

Slifkin asserted in this book that scientific theories including evolution theory, not only are fully compatible with the tenets of Judaism, but that all science is in fact rooted in the Torah.

paging Carol Clouser.

Carol Clouser to the front desk, please…

I’m so evil.

oh wait, i think i have to say it three times:

Clouser Clouser Clouser

there.

*ducks*

Perhaps ‘realpc’ will come along and derail the thread? He could expose his ignorance of James Randi again. Always entertaining.

Sir Toe - Stifle! ;)

Carol Clouser never responded to this????

Yeesh, I hope she’s alright… ;-)

Carol’s off protecting Africa’s zebras against the Nazi tactics of the hyenas.

Re Zebras - Trying to earn her stripes? :)

Henry

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Mark Perakh published on July 15, 2007 3:19 PM.

Gordy Slack interview was the previous entry in this blog.

Forrest and Gross: Biochemistry by design is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Categories

Archives

Author Archives

Powered by Movable Type 4.361

Site Meter