Anything Goes

| 1 TrackBack

Anything goes in science class in Florida if the “Evolution Academic Freedom” bill passes. The bill advanced strongly today, passing the Senate Judiciary Committee by 6 to 3, or 7 to 3 by another count. (We still have trouble counting votes.)

The bill’s first provision after its name is:

9 (2) As used in this section, the term “scientific

10 information” means germane current facts, data, and peer-reviewed

11 research specific to the topic of chemical and biological

12 evolution as prescribed in Florida’s Science Standards.

Who decides what is germane or peer reviewed? Individual teachers and students are given rights under the bill. This right is not precisely stated but in no way denied either, and they would need that right in order to enjoy the other rights granted under the bill. If everything from germane through peer-reviewed is one conjunction then topics must be both germane and peer reviewed, in at least one person’s opinion. Creationists will insist that anything of interest to them is germane, and they also claim, except when under oath, that specific scientific papers support creationism. They also claim indirect support from numerous other papers via quotation abuse, or quote mining as it is known online. If germane (in someone’s opinion) and peer reviewed (in someone’s opinion) are taken to be separate sufficient conditions then absolutely anything goes. Florida’s fine new science standards will just be “if you want to”.

The bill also states

16 views regarding chemical and biological evolution. The

17 Legislature finds that in many instances educators have

18 experienced or feared discipline, discrimination, or other

19 adverse consequences as a result of presenting the full range of

20 scientific views regarding chemical and biological evolution. The

But there is no scientific material that anyone has been inhibited from presenting. There is however a certain view that some people wish to pretend is scientific even while knowing it isn’t. That view is called creationism or intelligent design. If the bill is not to allow teaching creationism, it has no function or purpose.

Several states are considering similar bills, but today’s big news is the action in Florida. Brandon Haught of Florida Citizens for Science has an eywitness account as well as the text of a fine brief speech delivered to the Judiciary Committee by Florida middle school teacher Mary Bahr.

Get on over to Florida Citizens for Science to read the rest and comment.

1 TrackBack

The badly misnamed Academic Freedom Bill has advanced through the judiciary committee of the Florida senate. You can find an account of the event on the Florida Citizens for Science blog, and some additional commentary by Pete Dunkelberg on The Panda... Read More

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Pete Dunkelberg published on April 8, 2008 5:09 PM.

Truth Tickets was the previous entry in this blog.

Flunked, Not Expelled: Not Even Fox Likes It is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Categories

Archives

Author Archives

Powered by Movable Type 4.381

Site Meter