Agelaius phoeniceus
Photography Contest.
Joe Long, Honorable Mention.
Photography Contest.
Joe Long, Honorable Mention.
![[Fitness Landscape]](/uploads/2026/fitness_landscape.png)
Not too long ago I became aware that William Dembski had a new article (here) in the BIO-Complexity (the Discovery Institute’s house journal). And that a section of that article disputed my statements about smooth fitness landscapes (or fitness surfaces).
He is replying to a post by me here at Panda’s Thumb on 6 February 2025 (here). He and Robert Marks (and also Winston Ewert) had argued that there was a Conservation of Information law, that showed that when information gets into genomes, it must have already existed elsewhere. They said that this was even true when natural evolutionary processes put adaptive information into the genome – it must have already existed, for example, in the fitness landscape.
Their argument (which can be seen here and here) uses the concept of “active information”. For situations in which there is a population evolving on a fitness landscape, active information can include the information embodied in the assignment of fitnesses to genotypes.
Dembski, in his BIO-Complexity paper, summarizes my arguments thusly (the list is quoted from that article):
He argues that there are exceptions to all fitness landscapes being smooth, that I have conflated the No Free Lunch argument with his Conservation of Information argument, and that the latter is his essential argument.
Let’s look at his refutation in some detail:
I recently listened to Jared Diamond interviewed on an episode of The Michael Shermer Show: How Much Can One Person Change History? Diamond is probably best known for his book Guns, Germs, and Steel, which I had read when it came out. His newest book, published this fall, is Profits, Prophets, Coaches, and Kings: (When) Do Leaders Matter? The content of the book is well summarized in the Shermer Show and also reflected accurately in the titles. That said, when someone as bright as Diamond wonders about Darwin, I have to take notice, so I picked up the book and read it, followed by three reviews, in the Times, the Guardian, and the Globe and Mail. The Globe and Mail article was favorable, the Guardian article mixed, and the Times article properly critical but sometimes perhaps a bit catty.
Before we get to Darwin, let us back up a little bit and discuss what Diamond calls the Hamlet test.
Photograph by David Young.